Not every plumbing task requires a licensed plumber. Simple jobs like changing a faucet aerator or replacing a toilet flapper can often be done by a handyman—or even yourself. But more complex work, especially anything requiring permits, should only be done by a licensed professional.
Understanding the difference can save you money on simple tasks while protecting you from the risks of unpermitted or improper work on complex jobs.
Key Differences: Plumber vs. Handyman
| Factor | Licensed Plumber | Handyman |
|---|---|---|
| Training | 2-5 years apprenticeship, exams, continuing education | Varies widely; may have no formal training |
| Licensing | State or local license required | Usually no license required (varies by state) |
| Can Pull Permits | Yes | No |
| Insurance | Typically carries liability insurance | May or may not have insurance |
| Hourly Rate | $75 - $200/hour | $40 - $80/hour |
| Best For | Complex work, installations, repairs behind walls | Simple fixes, minor repairs, maintenance |
Jobs a Handyman Can Usually Do
These simple tasks typically don't require a plumbing license (check your local laws):
Fixture Repairs
- Replacing faucet aerators and handles
- Installing new showerheads
- Replacing toilet flappers and fill valves
- Fixing a running toilet
- Replacing toilet seats
Minor Repairs
- Unclogging drains with plunger or snake
- Replacing supply lines (braided hoses)
- Replacing P-traps under sinks
- Tightening loose connections
- Caulking around fixtures
Rule of thumb: If it doesn't require going behind walls, turning off the main water supply for extended periods, or modifying any pipes, a handyman can usually handle it.
Jobs That Require a Licensed Plumber
These tasks almost always require a licensed plumber and often need permits:
Installations
- Water heater installation or replacement
- Installing new fixtures (toilet, sink, tub)
- Adding new plumbing lines
- Relocating plumbing for remodels
- Water softener installation
Major Repairs
- Pipe repairs and replacements
- Sewer line repair or replacement
- Fixing leaks inside walls
- Main water line work
- Repiping (replacing old pipes)
Always Requires a Licensed Plumber:
- Gas line work - Always requires licensed plumber, often with gas certification
- Backflow prevention - Requires certified specialist
- Work requiring permits - Only licensed contractors can pull permits
The Gray Area: It Depends
Some jobs fall into a gray area where the answer depends on your local laws, the complexity of your specific situation, and your comfort level.
Toilet Replacement
If the flange and connections are in good shape, this can be a handyman job. But if the flange is damaged or needs repositioning, call a plumber.
Need Plumber: Flange repair, moving location, adding bidet connections
Faucet Replacement
Replacing a faucet where connections match up is simple. But if the new faucet requires different connections or valve modifications, it becomes plumber territory.
Need Plumber: New valve installation, pipe modifications
Garbage Disposal
Replacing an existing disposal with the same model is often handyman-friendly. A new installation with new electrical and plumbing connections typically needs professionals.
Need Plumber: New installation, drain modifications
Dishwasher Installation
If water and drain connections already exist, a handyman can handle it. If you need to add new connections, that's plumber work.
Need Plumber: Adding new water/drain lines
Legal Considerations by State
Handyman Exemption Laws
Many states have "handyman exemptions" that allow unlicensed workers to do minor plumbing work up to a certain dollar amount. This varies significantly:
- • California: Up to $500 for minor work
- • Texas: Varies by city; no statewide limit
- • Florida: Minor repairs under $1,000
- • New York: Varies by municipality
Check your state's specific regulations.
Why This Matters
Work done by unlicensed individuals may:
- • Not be covered by homeowner's insurance if it causes damage
- • Create problems when selling your home (unpermitted work)
- • Violate local codes, resulting in fines
- • Leave you with no recourse if work is defective
Cost Comparison
Here's what you might pay for the same tasks with a handyman vs. licensed plumber:
| Task | Handyman Cost | Licensed Plumber | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fix running toilet | $50-$100 | $150-$250 | ~$100 |
| Replace faucet (simple) | $75-$150 | $200-$350 | ~$150 |
| Unclog drain | $50-$100 | $150-$300 | ~$150 |
| Install showerhead | $30-$60 | $100-$150 | ~$70 |
Note: These savings assume the job goes smoothly. If a handyman encounters complications beyond their skill level, you may end up paying twice—once for the handyman and again for a plumber to fix the problem.
Decision Framework: Who Should I Call?
Ask yourself these questions:
Does the job require a permit?
If yes → Licensed plumber
Will you need to cut, solder, or modify pipes?
If yes → Licensed plumber
Does it involve work behind walls or under the slab?
If yes → Licensed plumber
Does it involve gas lines?
If yes → Licensed plumber with gas certification
Could a mistake cause significant water damage?
If yes → Licensed plumber
Is it a simple repair or replacement of accessible parts?
If yes to this AND no to all above → Handyman OK
When in Doubt, Call a Plumber
If you're unsure whether a job needs a licensed plumber, it's safer to call one. Most will give free or low-cost estimates and can tell you if the job is simple enough for a handyman.
The cost of hiring a professional upfront is almost always less than the cost of fixing damage from a job gone wrong.
Related Guides
Find Licensed Plumbers Near You
Search our database of verified licensed plumbers with real reviews from homeowners.
Search Plumbers